ZEPHYR 3.7 ANDROGYNE, CELIBACY, AND THE THIRD SEX3 ZEPHYR Other dimensions and awareness |
![]() |
![]() |
|
| Shiva and Shakti-Kali appeared as the androgyne Ardhanarisvara, the right side male, the left side female. | Chinese Taoists held the mandala Yang and Yin to represent androgyne |
androgynous - having both male and female characteristics. Collins New Pocket English Dictionary
A test for the girls to see how one-sided you are:
Which are you:
| 1. | EF - Extreme Femme |
| 2. | LF - Lipstick Femme |
| 3. | CF - Classic Femme |
| 4. | PF - Practical Femme |
| 5. | SF - Strong Femme |
| 6. | SA - Soft Androgyne |
| 7. | AN - Androgyne |
| 8. | HA - Hard Androgyne |
| 9. | GB - Gentle Butch |
| 10. | FB - Feminist Butch |
| 11. | CB - Classic Butch |
| 12. | BB - Boot Butch |
| 13. | EB - Extreme Butch
|
An interesting, amusing test at the following web-site - not to be taken as definitive but certainly defines androgyne and the grades on each side
http://members.tripod.com/~womens_voices
There is a good discernment between those struggling to come to grips with androgyne who will waver between hard androgyne and soft androgyne, before coming home to balance in pure androgyne.
celibate - 1. unmarried or abstaining from sex esp. because of a religious vow of chastity 2. celibate person
Abstinance or chosen celibacy? It is suggested in many eastern religions that abstinance is an opportunity to consider re-directing one's energy to higher matters.
The following interesting article on the Third Sex is taken from the following website
GALVA - Gay & Lesbian
Vaisnava Association
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/galva108/
http://www.nine9.ukshells.co.uk/galva108/
http://www.geocities.com/galva108/
By Amara Das Wilhelm
WELCOME TO THE GALVA 108 WEBSITE! This site is provided by the Gay and
Lesbian Vaishnava Association, an international organization dedicated to the
teachings of Lord Caitanya, the importance of all-inclusiveness within His
mission and the Vedic concept of a natural third gender. Its purpose is to
educate Vaishnavas, Hindus and the public in general about the "third
sex" as described in Vedic literatures. This knowledge will help to correct
many of the common misconceptions that people hold today concerning gay, lesbian
and other third-gendered persons.
Let me first offer my respectful obeisances unto my beloved gurudeva A.C.
Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada. Mindful of his desire to see all classes of
human society included within the Vedic system of spiritual upliftment, I humbly
attempt to write this paper. It is also my desire to help steer readers away
from the pitfalls of discrimination and hate based upon bodily distinctions, so
often the trap of mundane religionists.
In modern times, there has been much controversy concerning the position
and rights of gay and other third-gender groups within society. Should they be
feared and eliminated as a harmful, corruptive force within our midst? Should
they be ignored and hidden away, being denied the basic rights and privileges
that other citizens enjoy? Or should they be welcomed as simply another color
within the rainbow of human variety? The answer to these questions can be found
in the ancient Vedic literatures of India, which have thoroughly analyzed and
recorded all aspects of human behavior and knowledge since time immemorial.
After the Vedas were issued forth from Brahma at the beginning of
creation, Manu set aside the verses concerning civic virtues and ethics, thus
compiling the Dharma Shastra. Similarly, Brhaspati set aside the verses
concerning politics, economy and prosperity to compile the Artha Shastra. Nandi,
the companion of Lord Siva, set aside the verses concerning sense pleasure and
sexuality, thus compiling the Kama Shastra. The great sage Vyasadeva put this
Kama Shastra into writing approximately five thousand years ago along with all
other Vedic literatures. It was then subsequently divided into many parts and
almost lost until recompiled by the brahmana sage Vatsyayana during the Gupta
period or about 300 A.D.3 The result was the famed Kama-sutra or "codes of
sensual pleasure". Although commonly presented to westerners in the format
of an erotic sex manual, the actual unabridged Kama-sutra gives us a rare
glimpse into the sexual understandings of ancient Vedic India.
Throughout Vedic literature, the sex or gender of the human being is
clearly divided into three separate categories according to "prakriti"
or nature. These are: "pums-prakriti" or male, "stri-prakriti"
or female, and "tritiya-prakriti" or the third sex.
These three genders are not determined by physical characteristics alone
but rather by an assessment of the entire being that includes the gross
(physical) body, the subtle (psychological) body and a unique consideration
based upon social interaction (procreative status.) Generally the word
"sex" refers to biological sex and "gender" to psychological
behavior and identity. The term "prakriti" or nature, however,
implies both aspects together as one intricately woven and cohesive unit, and I
will therefore use the two words more or less interchangeably in this article.
People of the third sex are analyzed in the Kama-sutra and broken down
into several categories that are still visible today and generally referred to
as gay males and lesbians. They are typically characterized by a mixed
male/female nature (i.e. effeminate males or masculine females) that can often
be recognized within childhood and are identified by an inherent homosexual
orientation that manifests at puberty. The homosexual behavior of these people
is described in great detail within the eighth and ninth chapters of the second
part of the Kama-sutra. While gay males and lesbians are the most prominent
members of this category, it also includes other types of people such as
transgenders and asexuals.
The third sex is described as a natural mixing or combination of the male
and female natures to the point in which they can no longer be categorized as
male or female in the traditional sense of the word. The example of mixing black
and white paint can be used, wherein the resulting color gray, in all its many
shades, can no longer be considered either black or white although it is simply
a combination of both. People of the third sex are mentioned throughout Vedic
literature in different ways due to their variety of manifestations. They were
not expected to behave like ordinary heterosexual men and women or to assume
their roles. In this way, the third sex category served as an important tool for
the recognition and accommodation of such persons within society.
People of the third sex are also classified under a larger social
category known as the "neutral gender." Its members are called "napumsaka,"
or "those who do not engage in procreation."
There are five different types of
napumsaka people:
(1)
children,
(2)
the elderly,
(3)
neuters,
(4)
the celibate and
(5)
the third sex.
They were all considered to be sexually neutral by Vedic definition and were protected and believed to bring good luck. As a distinct social category, members of the neutral gender did not engage in sexual reproduction. This non-reproductive category played an integral role in the balance of both human society and nature, similar to the way in which asexual bees play out their own particular roles in the operation of a hive. In Hinduism there are no accidents or errors, and everything in nature has a purpose, role and reason for existence.
Vedic society was all encompassing and each individual was seen as an integral part of the greater whole. Thus all classes of men were accommodated and engaged according to their nature. Third-gender citizens were neither persecuted nor denied basic rights. They were allowed to keep their own societies or town quarters, live together within marriage and engage in all means of livelihood. Gay men could either blend into society as ordinary males or they could dress and behave as females, living as transvestites. They are especially mentioned as being expert in dancing, singing and acting, as barbers or hairstylists, masseurs, and house servants. They were often used within the female sections of royal palaces, and also engaged in various types of prostitution. Transvestites were invited to attend all birth, marriage and religious ceremonies as their presence was a symbol of good luck and considered to be auspicious. This tradition still continues in India even today.6 Lesbians were known as "svairini" or independent women, and were permitted to earn their own livelihood. They were not expected to accept a husband. Citizens of the third sex represented only a very small portion of the overall population, which most estimates place at approximately five percent. They were not perceived to be a threat in any way and were considered to be aloof from the ordinary attachments of procreation and family life. In this way they were awarded their own particular status and welcomed as a part of civilized Vedic society.
There is a strange being described within early British translations of
Vedic literature. These beings are comic, mythical creatures that appear to have
lost their relevance in modern times. They are described as neither man nor
woman, or sometimes as both man and woman. They are compared to the "gandharva"
or fairy and are believed to be asexual or without sex desire. Even Arjuna, the
eternal companion of Lord Krsna and the hero of the Mahabharata, became one of
these beings while hiding during his last year of exile, according to the Lord's
plan. There, dressed as a woman, he wore his hair in braids, behaved in a
feminine manner, and taught dancing and singing to young girls with no
attraction for them.
Welcome to the world of the so-called "Vedic eunuch," a term so
archaic and disingenuous it provides a good lesson both in semantics and social
denial. First of all, there is no recorded evidence of any system of male
castration in ancient Vedic India. Castration among servants and slaves was only
introduced into medieval Northern India with the arrival of foreign Islamic
rulers, sometime around the eleventh and twelfth centuries AD. Even then, it was
usually only homosexual males who endured the dark and gruesome practice. The
English word "eunuch", or castrated male, is Greek in origin and was
commonly used to refer to both homosexuals and castrated men during the Middle
Ages. When the term "homosexual" was first coined with the advent of
modern psychiatry in the late nineteenth century, British writers continued to
cling to the word eunuch, which was considered more polite by Victorian
standards. Thus they used the word loosely to describe both homosexual and
castrated men all over the world in regions ranging from Greece, Persia, India,
China, Polynesia, etc. During the nineteenth century, when Great Britain was the
major world power and had subjugated India, homosexuality was considered a sin
so horrific it was not even to be mentioned, let alone discussed. This resulted
in the use of vague, inappropriate terms to describe homosexual people such as
eunuch, neuter, impotent, asexual, hermaphrodite, etc. While these different
types of people exist to some degree and are included within the third-gender
category, they hardly would have made up its mass. Rather, by behavior and as
described in the Kama Shastra, the so-called "eunuchs" of ancient
India engaged almost exclusively in homosexuality.
The avoidance of this fact has lead to an erroneous understanding of the
"Vedic eunuch" and his relevance to modern times. Words used to
describe gay and lesbian citizens in Sanskrit were inaccurately translated to
skirt homosexual issues and impose puritan ethics upon Vedic literatures where
they did not otherwise exist. There are many examples of this, the most common
of which is the Sanskrit word "napumsaka" (literally "not
male"), which is used to refer to a man who has no taste for women and thus
does not procreate. While this may technically include diseased, old or
castrated men, it most commonly refers to the gay or homosexual male, depending
of course upon the context and behavior of the character being described. Other
Sanskrit words for people of the third sex include "sandha"
(half man, half woman) and "kliba" (non-reproductive). The
exact definitions and usage of these words are not entirely clear (most Sanskrit
words have many different meanings), and they also appear to be somewhat
interchangeable. Nevertheless, such words were plainly used to describe
homosexuals and other types of third-sexed people. It is foolish to assume that
they only referred to castrated men, especially in a society where castration
was not systematically practiced. Another good example of inaccurate translating can be found in the
Sanskrit word referring to lesbians or "svairini". Literally
meaning "independent woman," this word was commonly mistranslated by
early British scholars as "corrupt woman."
And when mentioning "maithunam pumsi," or simply
"sexual union between males," the so-called scholars have chosen as
their translation "the unnatural offense with a male."
Mistranslations such as these have only served to confuse and cover the acknowledgement of gay and lesbian people within Vedic literature, people who were nonetheless clearly recognized and defined in the Kama Shastra. In many instances, such persons were even demeaned or vilified by foreign commentators who did not understand or accept the Vedic concept of a third gender. We can only hope that future scholars and translators will be more accurate and forthright in their work.
The Vedic literatures are comprised of voluminous Sanskrit texts
numbering in the thousands, and their priestly authors were renowned for their
detailed descriptions of all sciences, both godly and mundane. To obtain a clear
understanding of human sexuality, behavior and practice, one is advised to
consult the Kama Shastra, which thoroughly covers this field. It is within these
texts where the most information is found regarding the third sex and its
members, behavior, practices and roles within society. A brief description will
be given here, taken mostly from the eighth and ninth chapters of the second
part of the Kama-sutra.
"People of the third sex (tritiya-prakriti) are of two kinds,
according to whether their appearance is masculine or feminine." Members of the third sex are first categorized according to whether their
physical characteristics are either male or female. These are known as "napumsaka,"
or gay males, and "svairini," or lesbians. Each of these
categories is then divided into two, depending upon whether their behavior is
either masculine or feminine. They are then further divided into many
sub-categories numbering well over twenty.
Homosexual people are the most prominent members of the third sex. While
appearing as ordinary males and females, their third-nature identity is revealed
by their exclusive romantic and sexual attraction for persons of the same
physical sex. Gay men share the attractions felt by ordinary females and lesbian
women share the attractions felt by ordinary males. Such people sometimes
exhibit other types of "cross-gender" behavior, but not always.
Under the heading of
tritiya-prakriti, or people of the third sex,
the lesbian is first described in the chapter of the Kama-sutra concerning
aggressive behavior in women (purushayita). The Sanskrit word "svairini" refers to an independent or
liberated woman who has refused a husband, earns her own livelihood and lives
either alone or in marriage with another woman. Her various types of homosexual
behavior and practices are described in great detail within this chapter.
Lesbians were more likely to marry and raise children than their male
counterparts and were readily accommodated both within the third-gender
community and ordinary society. Women of the third sex were engaged in all means
of livelihood including trade, government, entertainment, as courtesans or
prostitutes, and as maidservants. Sometimes they would live as renunciants and
follow ascetic vows.
Gay Men (Napumsaka)
The word "napumsaka" can refer to any non-reproductive
member of society, but in this instance it is specifically used to describe men
who appear as male but are actually members of the third sex. Gay men are
thoroughly described in the chapter of the Kama-sutra concerning oral sex (auparishtaka).
Oral sex is not recommended for heterosexuals and is forbidden to
brahmanas (priests), but it is acknowledged as the natural practice among those
of the third sex who are not otherwise engaged in celibacy.
Gay men with feminine qualities are first described. "Those with a
feminine appearance show it by their dress, speech, laughter, behavior,
gentleness, lack of courage, silliness, patience, and modesty." Gay men with feminine qualities are the most recognizable members of the
third sex. For this reason, they have often kept their own societies within all
cultures of the world. They generally keep long hair and arrange it in braids or
in a womanly fashion. Those who dress up as females are known as transvestites.
Feminine gay males were often professionally employed by aristocratic women and
commonly served within the royal palace. They are proficient in the arts,
entertainment and most notably dancing. As mentioned earlier, their presence at
marriage and religious ceremonies was considered to invoke auspiciousness, and
their blessings were much sought after.
The masculine gay male is next described. "Those who like men but
dissimulate the fact maintain a manly appearance and earn their living as
barbers or masseurs."
The masculine gay male is not as easily recognizable and would often blend into ordinary society, living either independently or within marriage to another man. Some were known to become professional male prostitutes who worked as masseurs. The technique of these masseurs is described in much detail. While effeminate gay men would keep smooth skin, apply make-up and sometimes don breasts, the masculine gay male would keep bodily hairs, grow moustaches or small beards and maintain a muscular physique. They would often wear shiny earrings. Gay men were talented in many different ways and were engaged in all means of livelihood. They often served as house attendants to wealthy vaishyas (merchants) or as chamberlains and ministers to government officials. Such men were renowned for their loyalty and devotion. Sometimes gay men would live as renunciants and develop clairvoyant powers. Those practicing celibacy were often used as "pujaris" (temple priests).
Gay males typically engaged in fraternal or casual love, but were
sometimes known to marry one another. "There are also third-sexed citizens,
sometimes greatly attached to each other and with complete faith in one another,
who get married (parigraha) together."
There were eight different types of marriage according to the Vedic
system, and the homosexual marriage that occurred between gay males or lesbians
was classified under the gandharva or celestial variety. This type of marriage
was not permitted for members of the brahmana community but often practiced by
heterosexual men and women belonging to the other classes. The gandharva
marriage is defined as a union of love and co-habitation, recognized under
common law, but without the need of parental consent or religious ceremony.
Transgenders (Sandha)
The Sanskrit word "sandha" indicates people who are
"half male-half female." This can refer to anyone of the third sex but
perhaps best describes people with transgender identity. These people do not
identify with their physical sex but instead consider themselves and live their
lives as members of the opposite sex. Transgender males identify and live as
women whereas transgender females identify and live as men. They are also
sometimes called transvestites or transsexuals and differ from gay males and
lesbians in that they do not identify as homosexual and are less common. It is
possible that in ancient times transgender males may have sometimes castrated
themselves in order to become more feminized. Nowadays, such people often
undergo hormone treatment and transsexual operations. In Vedic culture
transgender people were allowed to live openly according to their gender
identity, and this is demonstrated in the Mahabharata story of Arjuna as
Brihannala.
Asexuals (Kliba)
The word "kliba" can refer to any non-reproductive
person of the third sex. Sometimes it specifically implies impotent or barren
individuals whose genitals are either absent or useless (asexuals). Such people
are of two kinds: those born with defective sexual organs (chronic intersexuals)
and those who have had them damaged or removed (neuters). They may be
homosexual, heterosexual or sexually undefined by nature, and their degree of
impotency can vary greatly. People who are born asexual typically have a chronic
physical condition caused by the biological combination of the male and female
sexes known today as intersexuality. This condition, formerly known as
"hermaphroditism," leaves its members sexually dysfunctional,
unusually formed or sterile. According to Vedic texts, people are born this way
due to past sinful activities. Nevertheless, such people were respected for
their napumsaka status and treated kindly by Vedic society. They were
accepted according to their nature and typically lived within the larger
third-gender community where they shared similar roles.
In modern biology, the study of intersexuality and its various conditions
is relatively new. The concept of the male and female sexes combining on a
biological level, however, was already known by Vedic science many thousands of
years ago and corresponds with the tritiya-prakriti category. Most modern
researchers now suspect that biology, including genetic or inborn hormonal
factors, plays a significant role in determining not only a person's physical
sex but also their sexual orientation and gender identity. Indeed, homosexuality and transgender identity may very well
be some of the most common forms of intersexuality we know, and this would
explain why Sanskrit words describing people of the third sex are often used
interchangeably and why homosexuals, transgenders and asexuals are all
classified together.
It is a commonly held myth among some people that the third sex mentioned
in Vedic texts refers only to asexuals and not to homosexuals. While this view
is clearly contradicted in the Kama Shastra, it is also important to note that
asexuality is much less common within nature than homosexuality. On average,
chronic intersexuality occurs in approximately 1 out of every 36,600 births.
When this figure is compared to the estimated gay population of 5% or 1
out of every 20 births, it makes only 1 asexual person for every 1,830 gays and
lesbians. This disparity clearly demonstrates the predominate role of
homosexuals within the third-sex category.
Neuters are people whose asexuality is created by the unnatural damage or
castration of the genitals. Castration was not a common or accepted practice of
ancient India and mutilation of the body is discouraged in Vedic texts and
considered to be in the mode of darkness. Its
current illegal practice in Northern India among the "hijra" or
eunuch class has been attributed to the former centuries of Muslim rule that
once encouraged the practice. In South India, largely spared from Islamic rule
and influence, there is a third-gender class similar to the hijra known
as the "jogappa" but they do not practice castration. It should also be mentioned that castration was typically performed on
servants and slaves who were already homosexual by nature. The abused hijra
class of modern day India is the sad result of cruel social policies directed
against people of the third sex for almost a thousand years. Rejected by foreign
overlords who ridiculed and condemned any form of third-gender behavior as
intrinsically evil and unnatural, these citizens were abandoned as social
outcastes. Homosexual and transgender males could join the hijra class by
castrating themselves but were otherwise forced to marry women and pretend to
live as ordinary men. Unfortunately, this stifling social policy still remains
dominant in India today and has become accepted by most modern day Hindus.
Bisexuals (Kami)
The Kama-sutra thoroughly describes all types of sexual behavior and
practices between heterosexual or first and second gender men and women. This is
by far the major portion of the text. Within these chapters, bisexuality is
occasionally mentioned. Apparently, in Vedic times, bisexuality was considered
to be more of a variation for men and women who were so inclined, and not as a
category of the third sex. Because bisexuals engaged in the procreative act,
they did not possess the napumsaka nature of the third sex and other
sexually neutral people. The Sanskrit word "kami" indicates
that such persons were especially fond of lovemaking and that they displayed
this fondness in a variety of ways.
Bisexual feelings within heterosexual or homosexual people usually occur
at a rate of about ten or fifteen percent for either group. These feelings may range from very mild ones that are easy to ignore, on
up to stronger ones that require satisfaction. Bisexuality is a curious nature
in that it can move back and forth, thus involving the question of choice, which
is normally not an issue with heterosexuals or homosexuals. Heterosexuals often
confuse the homosexual nature with bisexuality, falsely considering
homosexuality to be merely a "choice" or "tendency". They
are unaware that the vast majority of homosexuals, or roughly ninety percent,
have absolutely no attraction, natural or otherwise, for members of the opposite
sex. Bisexuals themselves are often uncertain about their own sexuality,
especially during adolescence. In one survey, 35% of all bisexual people
reported to have previously identified as gay or lesbian earlier in life.
In any case, bisexuals were typically accommodated within ordinary heterosexual society but would also frequent the third-gender communities where they were similarly welcomed. Topics discussed in the Kama Shastra pertaining to them include: men who visit transvestites or masseurs working as prostitutes, men in the company of lesbians, transvestites within the kings harem, women of the harem satisfying themselves in lieu of the kings absence, and male servants who practice homosexuality in their youth but then later become inclined towards women.
Bisexual women (kamini) are mentioned in the Srimad Bhagavatam
within the chapter describing heavenly realms situated below the earth. In those beautiful regions, within celestial gardens and accompanied by
lesbians and nymphs (pumscali), bisexual women would entice men with a
cannabis beverage and enjoy sex to their full satisfaction.
In the Vedic system, different standards of behavior and sexual conduct
are prescribed for different classes of men. For example, the priestly order was held to high standards of conduct,
followed by the government officials. Merchants and farmers were given more
leniency, and ordinary workers and artisans, who made up more than half of the
population, were given more leniency still. This contrasts greatly with most
modern systems whereby all citizens are expected to follow the same laws. The
advantage of the Vedic system is that it is able to accommodate all varieties of
men within society according to their different natures.
It should be understood that the sexual behaviors described in the Kama
Shastra are intended for the Vedic citizen pursuing worldly enjoyment, which is
generally the aim of most people. They are not intended for those engaged in
vows, austerities and other penances that are recommended in the Vedas as a
means of attaining "moksha" or liberation from material
bondage. For this class of men (the spiritualists and brahmanas) only celibacy
is prescribed, even within marriage, and this is considered to be the highest
standard of conduct for those in the human form of life. However, Vedic culture
is all encompassing and thus, while ultimately encouraging renunciation, also
realistically accommodates other standards of behavior among common men.
In modern times, laws are drawn which artificially attempt to force all
citizens to adopt standards of conduct that are normally assigned to the
priestly class. From the Vedic perspective, however, sexual restraint is only
effective when it is voluntary. Laws were used to regulate "vice" by
establishing designated areas within the city or town and prohibiting it
elsewhere, such as in the brahmana or temple districts. Responsible
family life and celibacy were publicly encouraged and promoted by the
government, but at the same time other forms of sexual behavior were
acknowledged and accommodated accordingly. These include a wide variety of
activities such as prostitution, polygamy, sexually explicit art, homosexual
practices, the keeping of concubines, courtesans, etc. Anyone familiar with
Vedic literature will be well aware that these activities were allotted a
limited space within its culture.
They also continue to flourish even in modern times despite centuries of
prohibition. The puritanical concept of total prohibition of vice is a failed,
unrealistic system that causes widespread hypocrisy, disrespect for law and
injustice for many citizens. People of the third sex have especially suffered
under this system.
The sage Vatsyayana recognizes that sexual behavior varies from country
to country. People of the southern and western regions tend to be more relaxed
in their attitudes concerning sexual variation. Adhorata (anal
intercourse), for instance, is particularly practiced by people in the south.
While acknowledged as being occasionally practiced by all three sexes, it
is not recommended for any of them, including members of the third sex, and is
of course forbidden to brahmanas.
Its practice is said to divert the life-airs downwards and cause disease.
Regarding scriptural law, there are no verses in the Dharma Shastra that
specifically prohibit sexual behavior among people of the third sex. Two verses
admonish sexual intercourse among ordinary males (pums-prakriti) although
the punishment set is little more than a ritual bathing and both involve only brahmanas
or those of the twice-born class: "A twice-born man who engages in
intercourse with a male, or with a female in a cart drawn by oxen, in water, or
in the daytime, shall bathe, dressed in his clothes."
Another verse states: "Striking a
brahmana, smelling
obnoxious items such as liquor, cheating, and engaging in intercourse with a
male, are declared to cause the loss of caste." This loss of caste was not permanent since it could be atoned for, but it
is generally accepted that priests should always practice celibacy. Even married
priests were forbidden any sexual contact with their wives unless specifically
engaged to produce a child in strict accordance with the "garbhadhana-samskara"
process.
There are also no laws in the Dharma Shastra prohibiting sexual acts
between women except for two that involve the violation of young, under-aged
girls. In the Artha Shastra
relatively minor fines are given as punishment for sexual acts between males or
females committed in public view or within prohibited areas. The fines for males
are approximately four times the fines for females.
It is also interesting to note that heterosexual crimes such as adultery
and the pollution of women are punished quite harshly in the Dharma Shastra,
usually by corporal punishment or death. In comparison, the same texts take
little issue with homosexual behavior and seem to view it as rather harmless.
Other topics mentioned in the Dharma Shastra pertaining to people of the
third sex include: their excusal from ancestral worship and oblations ("sraddha");
their omission from family inheritance (unless they had progeny); the
recommendation that they, as well as women, should avoid offering food into the
sacrificial fire; and that ritualistic priests should not partake of such
offerings. Most of these
injunctions relate to the fact that people of the third sex did not appease
their forefathers and ancestral gods by producing progeny and were therefore
treated as ascetics. Fire sacrifices and other ritualistic ceremonies are mostly
intended for householders and not for renunciants or people of the neutral
gender. Sometimes, in the absence of women, heterosexual men forcibly engage in
homosexual rape with other men. This practice is condemned according to Vedic
literature. In the Srimad Bhagavatam it is narrated that at the beginning of
creation Lord Brahma generated the godless class of men from his buttocks who
then forcibly approached him for sex. To
appease them, Lord Brahma created twilight in the form of a beautiful woman who
completely captivated their lusty desires. This point of the story is important
to note because it clearly demonstrates that the demons were not members of the
third sex. This type of apparent homosexual behavior between first gender males,
as seen in prisons for instance where there are no females available, is
considered "demoniac and is not for any sane male in the ordinary course of
life." It should not be confused with the natural homosexuality described
in the Kama Shastra and practiced by people belonging to the third sex, acting
according to their nature and with affection.
In another well-known verse from the Mahabharata, Lord Siva explains to
Goddess Parvati why some men are born with severe physical handicaps such as
blindness, chronic illness or as neuters. In his answer to the latter category,
Lord Siva describes the fate of heterosexual men who indiscriminately engage in
sex without restriction: "Those foolish men of evil conduct who engage in
all forms of intercourse, taking advantage of improper wombs and with other
males, are born again without their organs (as neuters)."
Scriptural narrations such as these refer to first-gender males who
engage in reckless sexual behavior without discrimination. The word "viyoni"
or improper womb specifically refers to the womb of another man's wife, the
mother, sister, animal or child. Such actions are certainly condemned and
punishable under Vedic law but have nothing to do with people of the third sex
who are exclusively homosexual by nature. Gay males are described as gentle and
non-aggressive in Vedic literature and they typically engaged themselves among
their own kind. According to the Dharma Shastra, third-sex citizens were not
punished for their behavior under scriptural law.
It is said that a society can be judged by how it treats its minorities
and gentler classes. In Vedic civilization the cows, the brahmanas, women and
those belonging to the neutral gender (children, the elderly, neuters, the
celibate and the third sex) were all offered protection as an important social
principle. In modern times,
however, everything is topsy-turvy and thus these groups are now ridiculed,
exploited, persecuted and even killed, often under government sanction.
In Vedic society, people were familiar with the third sex and could
normally recognize its characteristics within their offspring. Since everyone
was accommodated under the Vedic system, third-gender youths could find their
place within society according to their nature and thus grow healthfully into
adulthood.
In modern society, however, people are afraid to even discuss third-sex
issues. Parents deny that their children are gay and try to force them to be
"straight". This causes psychological harm because it is against the
child's nature and creates friction and the fear of disappointing the parents.
In school, third-gender children are ostracized by others and abused both
verbally and physically. During adolescence, when others are dating and learning
how to form relationships, third-gender youths are isolated, forced to hide
their nature out of fear or shame. Alienated and confused in this way, they
contemplate suicide, and it has been found that the suicide rate for gay teens
is four times higher than that of their heterosexual peers. Those reaching
adulthood are discriminated against in the work force, legally denied housing,
scorned when they couple and forbidden the joys of marriage. Shunned by both
their relatives and society at large, people of the third sex are forced into
self-denial, often under the threat of criminal prosecution.
The most remarkable aspect of this gross mistreatment of third-sex people
in modern times is that it is all being done under the banner of so-called
morality and religion. These citizens are rejected as immoral and undeserving of
human rights solely on the basis of their romantic and sexual nature, which many
people mistakenly consider to be merely a "choice". This type of
social rejection and mistreatment is due to ignorance. Not understanding the
nature of the third sex, people become suspicious and fearful of their
differences. This produces bigotry, which then festers into hatred and
eventually violence. The disrespect and persecution of the third sex is a clear
sign of Kali-yuga, or the modern era of irreligion and hypocrisy described in
Vedic literatures. Under the Vedic system, these citizens were symbols of good
luck. They were protected and would bestow their blessings upon society. The
fact that they are now mistreated and oppressed can be seen as an omen of bad
times, and it is a poor measure of our humanity.
It is a common misconception among some that in Kali-yuga there is an increase in the ratio of homosexual people. Having researched this thoroughly, I have yet to find any Vedic verse supporting this claim. Rather, in the Vayu Purana it is stated, "in the Kali-yuga there will be more women than men." The foremost symptom of the Kali-yuga described is the marked increase in promiscuity among people of all genders. In the Bhagavad-gita it is stated that when irreligion is prominent, women become exploited and produce unwanted progeny, which then destroy the family tradition and become harmful to society at large. While homosexual promiscuity can lead to disease for those involved, heterosexual promiscuity is ensued by disease, adultery, unwanted children, contraception, divorce, broken families, abortion and so many social problems that directly affect the lives of other members of society. For this reason, the Dharma Shastra and other Vedic literatures strictly enforced the institution of marriage among heterosexual couples for the maintenance of the social structure. Homosexuality, on the other hand, was not taken as seriously under Vedic law and was not considered to be a social threat.
As a natural gender, the third sex has maintained a relatively fixed
presence within human society since time immemorial, despite varying social
policies. Indeed, its members will exist wherever there are males and females
themselves, and this will be true regardless of any fear, rejection or hate that
we may project upon and cause them to suffer. For our own good, therefore, and
by following the Vedic example of social morality and acceptance, we should
respect and treat all living entities equally, without consideration of gender.
The perfect example concerning the proper treatment of third-sexed people
can be found in the behavior of Maharaja Virata. This great king was the ruler
of the Matsya province in India during the time of Lord Krsna, or just over five
thousand years ago. When Arjuna went to approach the king for shelter, he had
assumed the form and nature of a transgender male, a member of the third sex.
Donned in a woman's blouse and draped in red silk, he wore numerous ivory
bangles, golden earrings and necklaces made of coral and pearls. His hair was
long and braided, and he entered the royal palace with the gait of a
broad-hipped woman. According to the Mahabharata, his feminine attire hid his
glory and at the same time it did not. He appeared just like the full moon when
eclipsed by the planet Ketu.
This portrayal of Arjuna's dress and behavior is very interesting because
it clearly reveals his third-sex status. It is the same behavior found in the
Kama Shastra describing transgender males who dressed-up and lived as females.
Most English translations use the archaic and evasive word "eunuch" to
describe Arjuna, but it should be noted that the castration of heterosexual men
does not cause them to adopt the psychological nature of females and behave in
such a womanly fashion.
Introducing himself as a professional dancer and musician trained by
gandharvas, Arjuna explained that he was expert in singing, hair decoration and
"all the fine arts that a woman should know." At first, Maharaja
Virata could not believe that Arjuna was actually a "half-woman." He
had never seen such a person who was simultaneously so stout and strong yet
feminine in behavior. He suspected that Arjuna was a great archer and even
offered his kingdom to him, but Arjuna would not relent, saying, "My lord,
the only string that I can twang is the string of the vina." After
exhibiting his skills before the court, Arjuna was tested by beautiful women to
ensure that he was actually third-sexed and thus free from any lust for females.
(Had he been merely a eunuch or neuter, the men of the palace could have
examined him for testicles.) The king was surprised yet pleased with Arjuna's
manner of speaking and agreed that he should live among the palace women and
instruct them in singing and dancing. In this way, Arjuna introduced himself as
the transgender male "Brihannala" and soon became a great favorite
within their chambers. Maharaja Virata instructed his daughter Uttara,
"Brihannala seems to be a high-born person. She does not seem to be an
ordinary dancer. Treat her with the respect due to a queen. Take her to your
apartments."
It is important to note that the king addressed Brihannala as a female,
accepting her transgender status. He did not ridicule or belittle her, and he
most certainly did not have her sent away or arrested. He also did not suggest
that Brihannala change her dress and behave as an ordinary male. Rather, he
accepted her nature as it was and offered her shelter and employment within his
royal palace. This kindness and respect offered by Maharaja Virata to Arjuna in
his transgender form of Brihannala is exemplary and should be followed by all
government officials and leaders of society.
In Vedic astrology, the nine planets are each assigned to one of the
three genders. The Sun, Jupiter and Mars are assigned to the masculine gender;
the Moon, Venus and Rahu are assigned to the feminine gender; and Mercury,
Saturn and Ketu are assigned to the third or neutral gender. These last three planets, labeled "napumsaka,"
are considered to be sexually neutral by their influence. This neutrality refers
to the fact that their natures are aloof from the business of procreating life
as compared to the male and female planets. For instance, Mercury governs
children, who have not yet entered puberty and do not become sexually aroused.
Saturn governs neuters and the elderly, who are by nature restricted from sexual
reproduction. Ketu, on the other hand, specifically concerns those who are
sexually fit but have no interest in the act of sexual procreation. These
include the celibate and people of the third sex.
Of all the planets, Ketu or the Moon's south node is the most indicative
of the third gender. Ketu is a
subtle planet that cannot be seen with the physical eye except indirectly during
the lunar or solar eclipse. It is represented by the tail of the snake or the
lower portion of the body. While considered mysterious and inauspicious in the
material sense, it is a "moksha karaka," or indicator for
enlightenment. People influenced by this planet are often psychic and
spiritually inclined. They frequently become monks, nuns and renunciants. Ketu
is the only planet not assigned an earthly direction. Rather, it signifies the
direction inward or "heavenward."
There are also twenty-seven nakshatras or stars that are important in
Vedic astrology. Of these, Mrgashira, Mula and Satabhisa are
assigned to the third or neutral gender.
Some astrological texts state that certain planetary alignments can cause
bisexual tendencies in otherwise ordinary men and women. Such alignments include
Venus in the sign of Virgo for women, or having Mars or Saturn in the seventh
house for men.
According to Vedic science, the intrinsic nature or sex of the living
entity is determined at the moment of contraception (not at birth). This is
related in the Dharma Shastra: "A male child is produced by a greater
quantity of male seed, a female child by the prevalence of the female; if both
are equal a third-sex child or boy and girl twins are produced; if either are
weak or deficient in quantity, a failure of conception results."
The practice of celibacy, or voluntary restraint from sexual activity, is
an important and much revered aspect of spiritual life within Vedic religion.
Its practice is said to conserve the stamina of the body, strengthen
mental resolve and direct the life-airs upward. It also helps to minimize bodily
and worldly demands in order to fully immerse oneself in spiritual rapture.
Celibacy is prescribed for the priestly class, the elderly and for those engaged
in study. It is highly recommended for sincere souls who are truly eager to make
advancement in spiritual life. According to Vedic tradition, the practice of
celibacy does not necessarily have to be life-long. It may also be practiced
within limited frames of time such as one year, one month, one fortnight, etc.,
according to one's vow, and much benefit can still be reaped.
One of the advantages for people of the third sex is that the practice of
celibacy often comes easily for them. This is due to their lack of attraction
for the opposite sex and the subsequent urge to couple, produce offspring and
engage in family life. It can be observed that the ratio of gay and lesbian
people living within temples and monasteries is generally higher than it is
within the ordinary population. Many cultures of the world specifically
encourage and train their third-gender children to enter into the priestly
order.
From a practical point of view, however, it is important to note that
most people will not be interested or able to engage themselves in strict
celibacy, especially during youth. Such
people should not be unnecessarily discouraged or rejected. Those who desire
spiritual advancement are advised to avoid sexual indulgence as far as possible,
according to their ability. For members of the third sex, this may be
accomplished in various ways such as minimizing sexual conduct, committing
oneself to a single partner or refraining from practices such as "adhorata."
The institution of religious marriage, which unites heterosexual couples for the
production of good progeny and protects the social fabric, was not considered a
necessary or relevant function for people of the third sex within Vedic
tradition since they did not engage in procreation by nature.
It is the duty of the
brahmanas to encourage and engage all
members of society in the many spiritual practices recommended in the Vedas.
This includes people of the third sex. No one is to be excluded or discouraged
from these practices because of class, character, social standing, gender, race,
etc. These practices gradually purify the heart and remove all bad, unwanted
qualities. Their importance exceeds and corrects all personal disqualifications.
They promote spiritual upliftment for society as a whole and awaken true love
for God in His multitude of forms such as Krsna, Rama, Vishnu, Narayana, etc.
These practices include: the chanting of the holy names of God, reading
important scriptures like the Bhagavad-gita and Srimad Bhagavatam, hearing from
self-realized souls, accepting a bona fide spiritual master or guru, viewing the
temple Deity, offering gifts and service to the temple Deity, watering the
Tulasi plant, visiting holy places of pilgrimage, bathing in sacred rivers like
the Ganges, observing festivals connected with the Lord, offering prayers to the
Lord, always remembering the Lord, and considering the Lord to be one's best
friend and most dearly beloved. The Appearance of Lord Caitanya
Lord Caitanya is revealed as an
avatar (incarnation) of God in the
Vedic scriptures, and He appeared in this world in Mayapura, India, in the year
1486 A.D.57 His mission was to deliver the downtrodden souls of the Kali-yuga
age by introducing the chanting of the holy names of God or "Hare
Krsna." Although appearing in a male form, He displayed the highest
sentiments of love for God by accepting the mood of the supreme Goddess, known
as Radhika. This divine combination of supreme God and supreme Goddess in the
form of Lord Caitanya is considered to be among the most confidential teachings
of Vedic literature.
As He appeared in this world, apparently just like an ordinary child, the
full moon was rising above the plains of the sacred Ganges River, accompanied by
Ketu, in the form of a lunar eclipse. In all places, the holy names of God were
resounded again and again. The following day, according to custom, all the area
residents crowded around to see the newborn child. Sages and rishis were aware
that a great event had just taken place. Many residents brought precious gifts
and the father, Jagannatha Misra, also gave profusely in charity to the brahmanas
and the poor. Not least among the guests were the dancers of the third-gender
community known as the "nartaka," who happily performed before
the Lord. These dancers were especially used for religious occasions.
Historically, people of the third sex have always played a prominent role in the
arts and entertainment, not just in India but also around the world. All of
these transvestites from the napumsaka or gay community were devotees of
the Lord, and they prayed to God to bless the child and grant Him a long life,
as was the custom. Jagannatha Misra then gave them some precious jewelry and
beautiful silks, and they continued with their dancing and singing of Hare
Krsna.
The nartaka dancers are also mentioned in the Srimad Bhagavatam during the pastime of Lord Krsna's entrance into Dvaraka. There, along with the dramatic actors, artists, poets and prostitutes, these dancers enthusiastically performed their art as an offering to the Lord. In reply, "the almighty Lord greeted everyone present by bowing His head, exchanging greetings, embracing, shaking hands, looking and smiling, giving assurances and awarding benediction, even to the lowest in rank."
These stories, and others such as the year spent by Arjuna as a
transvestite during exile, are significant because they demonstrate that not
only were people of the third sex present hundreds and even thousands of years
ago, but they were present within the Lords transcendental pastimes as well. It
shows that from the Vedic perspective, God does not discriminate against gays
but on the contrary welcomes their service and devotion, just as He does for
all.
Another important point to note is that people of the third sex were
utilized to bestow blessings. Blessings can only be bestowed by people who are
auspicious, yet transvestites were well known for their homosexual behavior and
often served as prostitutes. The answer to this apparent anomaly is that since
they belonged to the third gender, transvestites were considered sexually
neutral. In Vedic literature, the strongest bond within this material world is
said to be the attraction between man and woman. Combined, they create so many
attachments such as home, property, children, grandchildren, etc., all of which
entangle the living entity in samsara," the cycle of repeated birth
and death that is perpetuated through the procreative process. People of the
third sex were considered to be aloof from this attachment, particularly gay
males. They typically did not engage in procreation or family life, and this was
a special quality that made their status unique within civilized Vedic culture.
The traditionally rigid male and female roles as we know them today are
consistently broken and altered throughout the Vedic literatures by humans,
demigods and even the Supreme Lord Himself. Lord Siva has a very popular
half-man, half-woman form known as Ardhanarisvara… Cross-dressing is quite common among Lord Krsna's most
intimate cowherd boyfriends, the "priya-narma-sakhas," who act
as go-betweens in His loving affairs with Sri Radha… An important ritual at
the Jagannatha temple in Orissa involves a sequence in which a young man dressed
in female attire seduces Baladeva, the elder brother of Lord Krishna… These
countless stories and pastimes are far too numerous to mention herein, but their
light-hearted and flexible approach to both gender and gender roles is admirable
and well worth noting.
It is important that we appreciate a world filled with variety. There
will never be just one race, one gender, one color, one sound, or one anything.
The Vedas describe this material world as a reflection of an infinitely
beautiful, perfect and eternal spiritual world that has even more variety than
we can imagine. We are all a part of this variegatedness, and we all have our
own unique role to play. It is therefore pointless to argue over who is higher,
lower, more important, less important, etc.
You may ask someone, "Why are you gay?" and that someone may
reply, "Why are you a man or a woman?" In the material world, we are
all trying to enjoy in so many ways, and that may be one answer. Spiritually,
however, we all have our own individual, intrinsic nature, and part of that
nature is that we all serve God (Krsna) in the mood of a particular gender. That
loving mood is eternal and full of unlimited bliss.
Thank you for reading this paper. Please do not mistreat anyone,
anywhere. We are all brothers and sisters!
Hare Krishna Hare Krishna Krishna Krishna Hare Hare
Hare Rama Hare Rama Rama Rama Hare Hare
Appendix1
The following is a summary of ten important facts presented in this paper
according to the Vedic understanding, accompanied by their corresponding myths
or common misconceptions that have arisen in recent years.
Myth- There are only two categories of sex: male
and female.
Myth- Third-sex citizens
were not allowed to participate in Vedic society.
Myth- The Vedic eunuch was an asexual, castrated
male no longer relevant to modern society.
Myth- Homosexuality is a modern day occurrence
that is dangerously on the rise and could overtake us if not checked.
5.
Fact-
The third sex or nature is an inherent quality that its members are born with.
Myth- Everyone is born heterosexual, but some of
us are corrupted and decide or choose to become gay.
Myth- People of the third sex are by nature
sinful, immoral and corrupted persons.
Myth- Kali-yuga is
marked by an increase in the number of homosexuals.
8.
Fact-
Vedic society accommodated a wide variety of sexual conduct that was regulated by the government.
Myth- All members of Vedic society were forced
by law to follow strict brahminical standards of sexual conduct.
Myth- Homosexuals pose a serious threat to the
order and tradition of family life.
Myth- Homosexuals should
be denied certain rights in order to keep them in
San Francisco 04/05/67SP:
(Srila Prabhupada SP): Jagannatha Misra is father. He was…
whatever money and cloth and gold and silver… they were coming… he was also
distributing to poor man, some dancers. In India there is a system… what do
you call the eunuchs? Those who are neither male or female? What do you call
them? What is their name?
HD: (Hayagriva dasa) A combination of both?
SP: Yes.
HD: Male and female? Hermaphrodite.
SP: Eunuchs? What is the eunuch?
HD: Eunuch. A eunuch is a …
SP: Tell me that.
HD: Impotent… someone who's been castrated.
SP: Oh. That is called a eunuch.
HD: Eunuch.
SP: Rather, by nature, neither man nor woman.
HD: Oh. This is also called asexual. That is to say, no sex.
SP: No sex?
HD: Hermaphrodite means they have the physical characteristics of both
man and woman.
SP: Oh? At the same time?
HD: At the same time.
SP: I do not know exactly, but such people, they have their own society,
and their means of livelihood is, that whenever there is some good occasion…
marriage or childbirth, like that, so, they go there and pray to God that this
child may be very long-living. In this way they make some prayer and get some…
HD: These people. Now, I don't understand…
SP: …Yes. Saci devi is the mother of Lord Caitanya. She is sitting with
the child. And everyone is greeting and visiting and everyone is saying,
"Oh! Look how nice a child He is!"
HD: And these "asexual" people?
SP: They are dancing.
HD: They are dancing.
SP: Yes. They are chanting Hare Krsna. Like that. So. Hare Krsna dancing
is going there and visitors are coming and presenting very nice things. Yes.
His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada, founder of the Hare
Krsna movement of the western world, rarely discussed gay or third-gender
issues, but mentions it here in a conversation with one of his disciples. He is
referring to the transvestite dancers and their societies that still exist in
India even today. He is obviously trying to find a more appropriate word for the
outdated term "eunuch," which he had used in his writings when
referring to people of the third sex. He also acknowledges herein that he does
not exactly know the nature of these people.
As was proper for a sannyasi, His Divine Grace avoided discussing sexual
topics except in regard to their renunciation. He did, however, recognize the
Kama Shastra as "the science of sex," but gave it little regard in
comparison to other more important scriptures. He rarely discussed
homosexuality, and the few times he did were always in context as to how it
applied to first-gender or heterosexual males.
Despite this, and more importantly, was Srila Prabhupada's shining
example of conduct in dealing with his third-sexed disciples and friends. He
always gave them full support, encouragement and love. He never rejected anyone
as a candidate for Krsna consciousness. His warm friendships with openly gay
people such as Allen Ginsberg set an example that we would all do well to
follow.
Mahabharata, The Greatest Spiritual Epic of All Time.
B Anderson, Kenneth (Krishna Dharma). 1999. Badger, CA: Torchlight
Publishing, Inc.Braha, James T. 1986.
Ancient Hindu Astrology for the Modern Western Astrologer.
Hong Kong: Liang Yu Printing Factory.Buhler, G., trans. 1967.
The Laws of Manu.
Delhi:Motilal Banarsidass.Danielou, Alain. 1994.
The Complete Kama Sutra.
Rochester, VT: Park Street Press.Levacy, William R. 1999.
Beneath a Vedic Sky.
Carlsbad, CA: Hay House, Inc.Nanda, Serena. 1999.
Neither Man nor Woman, The Hijras of India.
Canada: Wadsworth Publishing Company.Patil, D. R. 1973.
Cultural History from the Vayu Purana.
Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass.Pattanaik, Devdutt. 2002.
The Man Who Was a Woman and other Queer Tales from Hindu Lore.
Binghamton, NY: Harrington Park Press.Raman, B. V. 1991.
Astrology For Beginners.
Bangalore: Raman Publications.Sharma, Arvind.
Homosexuality and Hinduism (as part of Homosexuality and World
Religions).
Valley Forge, PA: Trinity Press International.Subramaniam, Kamala. 1995.
Mahabharata. Bombay: Siddhi
Printers.Swami, A.C. Bhaktivedanta
(Prabhupada.)1987.
Srimad Bhagavatam.
Singapore: Bhaktivedanta Book Trust. 1996.
Krsna, The Supreme Personality of Godhead.
Herts, England: Bhaktivedanta Book Trust. 1998.
Bhagavad-gita As It Is.
Botany, Australia: Bhaktivedanta Book Trust. 1988.
Teachings of Lord Caitanya.
Botany: Bhaktivedanta Book Trust. 1996.
Sri Caitanya-caritamrta.
Botany, Australia: Bhaktivedanta Book Trust. 1982.
The Nectar of Devotion.
USA: Bhaktivedanta Book Trust.Swidler, Arlene.
Homosexuality and World Religions.
Valley Forge, PA: Trinity Press
International.Vanita,
Ruth and Kidwai,
Saleem.
Same-Sex Love in India.
2001. New York, NY: Palgrave
Vatsyayana, Kamasutra.
1977. New Delhi: R. & K. Publishing House.
Webster's New World Dictionary of the American Language. 1983.
New York, NY:Warner Books.
Alain Danielou,
The
Complete Kama Sutra 1.1.5-8. Among scholars, there is some diversity of
opinion as to the date of compilation of the Vedas by Srila Vyasadeva. According
to the scriptures themselves, they were compiled just prior to the beginning of
the Kali-yuga, or a little over five thousand years ago. See His Divine Grace A.
C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada's Srimad Bhagavatam 1.7.8, purport. Alain
Danielou, The Complete
Kama Sutra 1.1.13, 14 and p. 4.4.
There are many examples of these three divisions of gender in Vedic
literature. See Srimad Bhagavatam by His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami
Prabhupada
(4.17.26 and 8.3.24);
The
Complete Kama Sutra by Alain Danielou (2.9.1); Beneath a Vedic Sky by William R. Levacy (p. 363) and
The
Laws of Manu by G. Buhler (p. 84, Manusmriti 3.49).
These five types of people are assigned to the neutral gender according
to all Vedic astrological texts. This is based upon their non-procreative
status. Alain Danielou, The
Complete Kama Sutra p. 10.7 There is some diversity of opinion as to the
exact percentage of gays within modern society, what to speak of within ancient
India. Although the Kinsey studies are often cited as documenting that 10% of
the U.S. population is gay, most research with probability samples now place
that figure at 3-6%, with somewhat fewer females (N. California Community
Research Group, University of California at Davis.) As far as ancient India is
concerned, it can at least be observed that out of the thirty-six chapters of
the Kama-sutra, two are devoted to addressing homosexuality, which is just over
5% of the text.
Kamala Subramaniam,
Mahabharata,
p. 260-261. Arvind Sharma, Homosexuality and Hinduism, p. 48. "the limited practice of
castration in India raises another point significant for the rest of the
discussion, namely, whether rendering a word such as kliba as eunuch regularly
is correct…" Ruth Vanita and Saleem Kidwai, Same-Sex Love in India, p.
109.11 Webster's New World Dictionary of the American Language, p.211.
[<Gr. "eune," bed + "echein," have] See Part Two, Chapter
Nine of The Complete Kama
Sutra by Alain Danielou. Alain Danielou, The Complete Kama Sutra, p. 6. Arvind Sharma,
Homosexuality
and Hinduism, p. 51. Alain Danielou, The Complete Kama Sutra 2.9.1.
Ibid. 2.8. Ibid. 2.9. Ibid. 2.9.2. Ibid. 2.9.6. Ibid. 2.9.36. Ibid. p. 227.
Mahabharata 13.145.5223
The American Psychological Association, Public Interest Report (revised version,
7/98). This average is based on statistics provided by the Intersex Society of
North America, taken from an article by Brown University professor Anne
Fausto-Sterling reviewing medical statistics from 1955-1998.
Self-mutilation as a form of penance is condemned by Lord Krishna in the
Bhagavad-gita
As It Is 17.19, and by Lord Siva in Krsna, The Supreme Personality of
Godhead, Volume Two p. 425-427 by His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta
Swami Prabhupada. Serena Nanda, Neither
Man nor Woman, The Hijras of India, p. 160. These estimates are somewhat unclear due to the wide range of bisexual
feelings themselves. The Kinsey study reported that 15-25% of women and 33-46%
of men reported experiencing at least some degree of same-sex attraction during
their lives. This survey was conducted by Dr. Ron C. Fox, a psychotherapist from
San Francisco. This latter example is given in Jayamangala by Yashodhara (The Complete Kama Sutra,
p. 191.) His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada, Srimad Bhagavatam
5.24.16. Instances of this can be found throughout Vedic literature, especially
in the Dharma Shastra such as Manusmriti,
Manu-samhita, etc. There are many examples throughout Vedic literature.
See Srimad Bhagavatam,
1.11.19, and Krsna,
The Supreme Personality of Godhead, Chapter 48 by His Divine Grace A.C.
Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada for examples concerning prostitution and sexually
explicit art. Alain Danielou, The Complete
Kama Sutra 2.6.49. G. Buhler, trans., The Laws of Manu, p. 466 (Manusmriti 11.175.) Ibid. p. 444.
(Manusmriti 11.68.) See His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada's Srimad
Bhagavatam 1.4.25, purport. G. Buhler, trans., The Laws of Manu p. 466. (Manusmriti,
8.369-370.) Arvind Sharma, Homosexuality
and Hinduism, p. 58. G. Buhler, trans., The Laws of Manu (Manusmriti
3.150, 9.201 and 203, 4.205 and 206) respectively. His Divine Grace A.C.
Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada, Srimad Bhagavatam 3.20.18-37. Ibid. 3.20.26, purport.
Mahabharata
13.145.52.
The word "viyoni" or improper womb refers to the womb of
another man's wife, the mother, sister, animal or child. It is commonly
mistranslated to mean "anything other than the female organ" in order
to vilify homosexual people. The following verses support the principle of
protecting people of the third gender, although neuters, the celibate and the
transgender sex are not specifically mentioned. See His Divine Grace A.C.
Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada's Srimad
Bhagavatam 1.14. and 1.8.5, purport. There is also the example of
Maharaja Virata, which is described later. The American Journal of Public Health
(June 2001) In research conducted by George Washington University, the Center
for Applied Behavioral and Evaluation Research in Washington, D.C., and the
Massachusetts Department of Education, gay students were about four times as
likely to have attempted suicide as straight students (36.1% vs. 9.4%), and
reported threats or assaults almost five times more often (28.3% vs. 6.9%.) D.
R. Patil, Cultural History from the Vayu
Purana, p. 75. His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada, Bhagavad-gita
As It Is 1.40-43.
The name "Brihannala" can comically be translated as
"big rod." This narration of Maharaja Virata's example is adapted from
Kamala Subramaniam's Mahabharata and Krishna Dharma's Mahabharata, The Greatest
Spiritual Epic of All Time. See William R. Levacy's, Beneath
a Vedic Sky, p. 363, and also B. V. Raman's Astrology For Beginners,
p. 6, where the third gender is listed as "hermaphrodite." B.V. Raman,
Astrology For Beginners,
p. 7 and William R. Levacy, Beneath
a Vedic Sky, p. 363. William R. Levacy, Beneath a Vedic Sky, p. 202-203. Ibid. p. 62-63. James T. Braha,
Ancient Hindu Astrology for the Modern Western Astrologer, p.
148 and 152. In this text bisexual tendencies are taken to be the same as
homosexuality. Manusmriti 3.4955 His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami
Prabhupada, Bhagavad-gita As It Is 8.11. Ibid. purport. See His Divine Grace
A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada's Teachings of Lord Caitanya or Sri
Caitanya-caritamrta. This is elaborately explained in His Divine Grace
A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada's Sri
Caitanya-caritamrta, Adi-lila Chapter 4 entitled "The Confidential Reasons for the Appearance of Sri Caitanya
Mahaprabhu." Ibid. 1.13.106. The purport also offers a short
description of the "eunuch" class. Ibid. Adi-lila Chapter 13 entitled "The
Advent of Lord Sri Caitanya Mahaprabhu."
There is also an audiotape by His Divine Grace on this pastime produced by The Bhaktivedanta Tape Ministry entitled Outline of Lord Caitanya Play, Part One, Tape #67-002, San Francisco, 04/05/67. 61 His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada, Srimad Bhagavatam 1.11.20-22. Devdutt Pattanaik, The Man Who Was a Woman and Other Queer Tales from Hindu Lore, p.125. This book contains a treasure trove of stories demonstrating just how mutable sex and gender identity are within Vedic/Hindu texts. His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada, The Nectar of Devotion, p. 332 and 387-388. Serena Nanda, Neither Man nor Woman, The Hijras of India, p. 22.Copyright MMAll rights reserved
|
Other dimensions and awareness |
|
3.4 - Ascension, Decension, The Second Coming and the Time of Redemption |
|
3.7 ANDROGYNE, CELIBACY, AND THE THIRD SEX |
| Would you like to go back to ENTRANCER - touch of transformation Home Page - the Main Entrance? |
| Would you like to go back to the ENTRANCER EXTENSION page to look for more types of articles? |